Experts weigh in as trade aid muddies late planting decisions


The 2019 planting season has been a challenge for Ohio farmers, as over-saturated soils have stalled corn and soybean planters for most of the month of May.

Adding to the frustration of not getting the crop in the ground is the uncertainty of what decisions need to be made in order for farmers to have the least damaging financial impact due to negative situations – including delayed planting and trade wars.

Crop insurance final planting dates are fast approaching and one of the options farmers have is to take Prevent Plant for acres they haven’t been able to sow. This type of claim is part of a Revenue Protection or Yield Protection crop insurance policy.

“On the most common policy for corn, the claims adjuster will look at your guarantee and will pay out 55% of that guarantee as your prevent plant payment,” said Jason Williamson, an agent with Williamson Insurance in northwest Ohio. “For soybeans, 60% of your guarantee is included in the policy.”

Williamson said the term ‘final planting date,’ which is June 5 for corn and June 20 for soybeans, can be misleading.

“Those timelines are the final plant dates for full coverage,” Williamson said. “Farmers can continue to plant corn well after June 5th because there is a 20-day late planting period for corn and corn planted in that time frame can be insured, but your guarantee will go down 1% per day after June 5th.”

Other Prevent Plant options include:

  • Not planting a crop and receiving a prevented planting payment,
  • Planting the acreage to another crop after the late planting period ends and receiving a reduced prevented planting payment, or
  • Planting a cover crop and receiving a full prevented planting payment, provided that the cover crop is not hayed or grazed before Nov. 1 or otherwise harvested at any time.

Adding to the complexities is a new round of Market Facilitation Program payments recently announced by the Trump administration to offset losses being felt in farm country due to trade woes with China. Under this trade aid, producers of alfalfa hay, barley, corn, oats, sorghum, soybeans, wheat and a long list of other commodities will receive a payment based on a single county rate multiplied by a farm’s total plantings to those crops in aggregate in 2019. Those per acre payments are not dependent on which of those crops are planted in 2019.

“While the administration was very sensitive about not impacting planting decisions between the commodities, they did create some more uncertainty because we have producers that might have been considering Prevent Plant that are now saying that they need to plant a crop to get a payment,” said Ben Brown, manager of Ohio State’s Farm Management Program. “It’s like that old saying ’one in the hand, two in the bush.’ The Prevent Plant is the one in the hand as producers know what the payment is going to be based on the coverage level and historical data, but we are sitting here wondering what the trade aid payment is going to be.”

Now, back to which option, Prevent Plant or MFP payments, would offer the most beneficial outcome to an individual farmer? There is no clear cut answer, but according to USDA, it does have to be one or the other. So, how does a farmer know if planting corn late into June will be the right choice?

“There are some parcels of land in parts of the state that respond differently but agronomists will tell you that every day that passes takes a yield hit from the full potential. We have a decent idea of how well corn can produce in a season but the unknown factor of weather adds to the challenges of a later planted corn crop,” Brown said. “The other thing to take into consideration is that if we start to see large acres of corn come out of production due to Prevent Plant we are going to see some increases in corn price and that has already taken place. The reason I bring this up is because most producers in Ohio have a revenue crop insurance plan that takes into account the harvest price. So, if we come to October and we have really high corn prices, that will increase the revenue guarantee for the crop insurance program. Yield is important but in a case like this year, price will be important as well.”

Bringing the trade aid package into the conversation is adding confusion to an already complicated late planting season.

“The biggest misconception that I have heard over and over is that the government is going to bump up Prevent Plant payments through the market facilitation programs to 70% or 90% and that is completely inaccurate,” Williamson said. “It is possible that something might come through the disaster assistance bill, but we won’t know that for a long time and nothing like that is set in stone.”

The $19.1 billion disaster aid bill passed the Senate but has been stymied by the House until Congress is back in session in early June.

Putting politics, trade disputes and disaster aid aside, farmers have one very heavy thought on their minds. They want to do what they are suppose to do this time of year and get their crops planted.

“I have talked with countless farmers that see Prevent Plant as a very last resort because they do not want to let any field set idle,” Williamson said. “It is a very frustrating topic of conversation and farmers are just getting ticked off that they have to talk about it. They won’t give up and if a crop can go in the ground I am convinced that farmers will do everything they can to make it happen, if Mother Nature will give them a break.”

The answers to all of these questions depends largely on the current situation of the farm, and each producer should visit with their crop insurance specialist to find a suitable solution.

Ty Higgins, OFBF media relations director, discusses these issues more in depth with Jason Williamson and Ben Brown on the latest Ohio Farm Bureau podcast.

One thought on “Experts weigh in as trade aid muddies late planting decisions

  1. Avatar Randall Reeder says:

    Thanks for compiling these details. I’m glad “Prevent Plant” is seen as a last resort by most farmers. Note, that if no crop can be planted, a good cover crop mix is an option that will help build soil health and increase yields in the future. Ohio has several experts in cover crops who can help decide on the best mix leading up to the 2020 cash crop. Investing $25 to $40 in cover crop seed/planting could turn out to be a good decision.

Leave a Reply to Randall Reeder Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *