OFBF Logo
    • Current Location
    • Adams
    • Allen
    • Ashland
    • Ashtabula
    • Athens
    • Auglaize
    • Belmont
    • Brown
    • Butler
    • Carroll
    • Champaign
    • Clark
    • Clermont
    • Clinton
    • Columbiana
    • Coshocton
    • Crawford
    • Cuyahoga
    • Darke
    • Defiance
    • Delaware
    • Erie
    • Fairfield
    • Fayette
    • Franklin
    • Fulton
    • Gallia
    • Geauga
    • Greene
    • Guernsey
    • Hamilton
    • Hancock
    • Hardin
    • Harrison
    • Henry
    • Highland
    • Hocking
    • Holmes
    • Huron
    • Jackson
    • Jefferson
    • Knox
    • Lake
    • Lawrence
    • Licking
    • Logan
    • Lorain
    • Lucas
    • Madison
    • Mahoning
    • Marion
    • Medina
    • Meigs
    • Mercer
    • Miami
    • Monroe
    • Montgomery
    • Morgan
    • Morrow
    • Muskingum
    • Noble
    • Ottawa
    • Paulding
    • Perry
    • Pickaway
    • Pike
    • Portage
    • Preble
    • Putnam
    • Richland
    • Ross
    • Sandusky
    • Scioto
    • Seneca
    • Shelby
    • Stark
    • Summit
    • Trumbull
    • Tuscarawas
    • Union
    • Van Wert
    • Vinton
    • Warren
    • Washington
    • Wayne
    • Williams
    • Wood
    • Wyandot
  • Join
  • Renew
  • Login
  • OFBF Calendar Icon
  • OFBF Search Icon
  • About Us
    • What is Ohio Farm Bureau?
    • News Room
    • Podcasts
    • Job Postings
    • Farm to Table
    • Nationwide Insurance
    • All Ohio Agriculture
  • Membership
    • Membership Overview
    • Ohio Farm Bureau Membership
    • Benefits
    • Business Solutions
    • Ag Intelligence Service
    • Membership Auto-Renew
    • Group Membership
    • Tools and Resources
    • FAQ
  • Advocacy
    • Advocacy Overview
    • 2026 Priority Issues
    • 2026 Elections
    • Ask Our Experts
    • All Advocacy
  • Community
    • Community Overview
    • County Farm Bureaus
    • Event Calendar
    • Young Ag Professionals
    • Youth in Agriculture
    • Grants
    • All Community
  • Foundation
    • Foundation Overview
    • Scholarships
    • Scholarships Criteria
    • Make a Gift
    • Legacy Giving
    • Meet our Board
  • Shop
  • OFBF Calendar Icon
  • OFBF Hamburger Icon
    • About Us
      • What is Ohio Farm Bureau?
      • News Room
      • Podcasts
      • Job Postings
      • Farm to Table
      • Nationwide Insurance
      • All Ohio Agriculture
    • Membership
      • Membership Overview
      • Ohio Farm Bureau Membership
      • Benefits
      • Business Solutions
      • Ag Intelligence Service
      • Membership Auto-Renew
      • Group Membership
      • Tools and Resources
      • FAQ
    • Advocacy
      • Advocacy Overview
      • 2026 Priority Issues
      • 2026 Elections
      • Ask Our Experts
      • All Advocacy
    • Community
      • Community Overview
      • County Farm Bureaus
      • Event Calendar
      • Young Ag Professionals
      • Youth in Agriculture
      • Grants
      • All Community
    • Foundation
      • Foundation Overview
      • Scholarships
      • Scholarships Criteria
      • Make a Gift
      • Legacy Giving
      • Meet our Board
    • Shop

    Email Successfully Sent

  • Home
  • All Articles
  • Legal With Leah: Lake Erie Rights Court Ruling
  • Article

    Legal With Leah: Lake Erie Rights Court Ruling

    Amanda Kolitsos | Posted on

    October 15, 2018



    Legal with Leah

    Two wins occurred on the legal front for farmers who faced potentially troubling rulings dealing with agriculture and water quality. Farm Bureau policy counsel Leah Curtis shares the good news.

    Some excerpts:

    Joe Cornely: There have been two recent developments on the legal front both attached to the farming and water quality discussion. Farm Bureau Policy Counsel Leah Curtis helps us dig through what happened. First of all there was a proposal to give Lake Erie its own rights. Tell us about that.

    Leah Curtis: Yes so this was an initiative to make changes to the Toledo City Charter which would have given the lake rights and standing to pursue those rights in Toledo’s municipal courts. And it also would have given citizens the ability to file on behalf of the lake to to put forth those rights as well.

    Joe Cornely: So this was a combination from some local activist organizations and then some national groups too that brought this motion forward. What happened?

    Leah Curtis: So they did collect signatures. They submitted it to the local Board of Elections. The Board of Elections rejected it on the basis of several Supreme Court rulings that say creating a new cause of action is something that’s outside the scope of municipal power and municipalities can’t change their charters to include things that are outside the scope of their power. Those who supported it then appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court to try to get it on the ballot. We filed an amicus brief to talk about the concerns about allowing things that are outside the scope of that municipal power to be put on the ballot.

    Joe Cornely: A federal judge, Judge Carr, has been weighing in for months now on the ways to go about fixing Lake Erie. Who is he and what’s his exact role here?

    Leah Curtis: Judge Carr is a federal district judge in the northern district of Ohio. That’s the federal district courts that cover northern Ohio including Toledo, and the Environmental Law Policy Center filed a lawsuit in his courtroom in that district which was then assigned to him that first asked them to review U.S. EPA action in approving Ohio’s impaired waters list and then they later asked for a change to their complaint to instead argue that U.S. EPA  acted unlawfully by not requiring what’s called a TMDL, a total maximum daily load for Lake Erie.

    Joe Cornely: So this is just a totally subjective viewpoint. What I’ve read the judge seems to sympathize with those that want a TMDL and yet in this ruling, it went the other way.

    Leah Curtis: The judge has to look at all the evidence available and he has to look at it in the best light for the other party that’s not motioning and determine if there’s still a claim. And he said that based on all the information available it is clear that US EPA had not acted unlawfully and that they did have time still to consider what should be done in response to Ohio listing Lake Erie as impaired.

    Listen to Legal with Leah, a podcast featuring Ohio Farm Bureau’s Policy Counsel Leah Curtis discussing topics impacting farmers and landowners.Ohio Farm Bureau membership

    New and beginning farmers
    My first recommendation in your journey is to start out with a local farming friend or mentor along with joining an organization like Ohio Farm Bureau.
    Greg McGlinch's avatar
    Greg McGlinch

    Darke County Farm Bureau

    Growing Tomorrow Grant
    We’re just so thankful for the Farm Bureau and the foundation for helping put this together. And of course, the Boyert family for the vision they had with this grant. It’s jumping us forward 10 years. It’s unbelievable.
    Nathan and Jill Parriman's avatar
    Nathan and Jill Parriman

    Clermont County Farm Bureau

    Bringing the farm back to life
    I could not have done it without the resources I have found through Farm Bureau.
    Gretchan Francis's avatar
    Gretchan Francis

    Trumbull County Farm Bureau

    Youth pathways in Farm Bureau
    It wasn’t until I joined the Wilmington College Collegiate Farm Bureau that I truly saw how my passion could translate into leadership, advocacy and a career.
    Wyatt Morrow's avatar
    Wyatt Morrow

    Clinton County Farm Bureau

    Giving farmers a voice
    The issue of property taxation remains as one of the biggest challenges our members face today. Ensuring agricultural property is valued for its agricultural potential and not development is critical to the continued success of Ohio agriculture.
    Matt Aultman's avatar
    Matt Aultman

    Darke County Farm Bureau

    Select Partner Program
    Through the Select Partner program, we became educated in farm insurance and weren't just selling policies. It became more and more clear why farmers need an advocate like Ohio Farm Bureau.
    Chad Ruhl's avatar
    Chad Ruhl

    Farm manager, CSI Insurance

    Advocacy
    So many of the issues that OFBF and its members are advocating for are important to all Ohioans. I look at OFBF as an agricultural watchdog advocating for farmers and rural communities across Ohio.
    Mary Smallsreed's avatar
    Mary Smallsreed

    Trumbull County Farm Bureau

    Suggested Tags:
    Lake ErieLake Erie Bill of RightsLegal with LeahWater Quality
    View All

    Featured Articles

    Applications for Ohio Farm Bureau Health Plans now available

    Members have three ways to apply: contacting a certified agent, calling 833-468-4280 or visiting ohiofarmbureauhealthplans.org.

    Read More
    Gripp business solution to establish Ohio test group

    Gripp is launching a 60-day cohort in mid-January for Ohio Farm Bureau members, offering discounted access to its asset-tracking app.

    Read More
    Ohio must not make it easier to seize your property for data centers, other projects

    Ohio Farm Bureau recently published an op-ed in The Columbus Dispatch highlighting the importance of protecting private property rights as discussions continue around expanding eminent domain powers in Ohio.

    Read More
    What would Grandma and Grandpa have wanted?

    These discussions should not begin and end with a developer’s offer. Identifying family goals now gives the family something to plan around.

    Read More
    Ohio Farm Bureau, partners pack 10,000 meals to kick off Food and Farms Month 

    Ohio Farm Bureau joined leaders from across Ohio’s food and agriculture industry this week to pack 10,000 meals for central…

    Read More
    Ohio Farm Bureau supports expanded use of dyed diesel

    The administration recently issued an executive order easing restrictions on the use of tax-exempt dyed diesel fuel for on-road agricultural transportation.

    Read More
    Legal with Leah: Eminent Domain and Quick Take

    Ohio Farm Bureau Associate General Counsel Leah Curtis explains how the eminent domain process works in Ohio, what ‘quick take’ means and when it can be used.

    Read More
    Ohio Farm Bureau statement on gas tax holiday

    As fuel prices skyrocket across the state,  lawmakers are preparing to return to the Statehouse to vote on the temporary suspension of Ohio’s gas tax.

    Read More
    Ohio’s 2026 top conservation farmers honored

    Since 1984, the Conservation Farm Family Awards program has recognized Ohio farm families for their exemplary efforts conserving soil, water, woodland, wildlife, and other natural resources.

    Read More
    Growing our Generation: A life of service

    Meet Joe Everett, a Shelby County Farm Bureau Young Ag Professional who has dedicated his life to service, both in uniform and within his local community.

    Read More
    View All
    OFBF Logo
    Navigate
    • About Us
    • Membership
    • Advocacy
    • Community
    • Foundation
    • Shop
    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Staff and Board Directory
    • Job Postings
    • Privacy Policy & Terms Of Use
    • Advertise With Us
    • County Farm Bureaus
    Membership
    • Join
    • Login
    Get In Touch

    Got questions or feedback?
    We'd love to hear from you.

    • Facebook Icon
    • X Icon
    • Linkedin Icon
    • Instagram Icon
    • Youtube Icon
    • TikTok Icon

    Ohio Farm Bureau Federation is a member of American Farm Bureau Federation®, a national organization of farmers and ranchers including Farm Bureau® organizations in 49 other states and Puerto Rico, and is responsible for Farm Bureau membership and programs within the State of Ohio. Ohio Farm Bureau Federation programs and services are available only to Farm Bureau members within Ohio. The political views expressed in these pages represent Ohio Farm Bureau Federation's positions on various issues as they relate to Ohio. The positions of the national Farm Bureau organization collectively are expressed through American Farm Bureau Federation. Any opinions, statements or views expressed through comments or by outside contributors are the express views of those individuals and do not necessarily represent the views of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation.

    OFBF Logo
    • Facebook Icon
    • X Icon
    • Linkedin Icon
    • Instagram Icon
    • Youtube Icon
    • TikTok Icon
    Navigate
    • About Us
    • Membership
    • Advocacy
    • Community
    • Foundation
    • Shop
    Resources
    • Contact Us
    • Staff and Board Directory
    • Job Postings
    • Privacy Policy & Terms Of Use
    • Advertise With Us
    • County Farm Bureaus
    Get In Touch

    Got questions or feedback?
    We'd love to hear from you.

    Ohio Farm Bureau Federation is a member of American Farm Bureau Federation®, a national organization of farmers and ranchers including Farm Bureau® organizations in 49 other states and Puerto Rico, and is responsible for Farm Bureau membership and programs within the State of Ohio. Ohio Farm Bureau Federation programs and services are available only to Farm Bureau members within Ohio. The political views expressed in these pages represent Ohio Farm Bureau Federation's positions on various issues as they relate to Ohio. The positions of the national Farm Bureau organization collectively are expressed through American Farm Bureau Federation. Any opinions, statements or views expressed through comments or by outside contributors are the express views of those individuals and do not necessarily represent the views of the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation.

    County

    Join

    Account

    Search