U.S. EPA’s denial to transfer permitting from Ohio EPA to ODA doesn’t change a thing with the state’s livestock permitting process.Read More
Can you trim a tree overhanging the property line? Who is liable if a tree from a neighboring property falls and damages your property? In this Legal with Leah, Ohio Farm Bureau Policy Counsel Leah Curtis answers the most common questions about Ohio laws regarding trees and property rights.
Listen to Legal with Leah, a podcast featuring Ohio Farm Bureau’s Policy Counsel Leah Curtis discussing topics impacting farmers and landowners.
Ty Higgins [00:00:00] It’s one of the most clicked articles on Ohio Farm Bureau’s website, because it pretty much affects everybody, whether you have trees on your property or your neighbor has trees on their property. Talking about trees and property rights and this one is personal to me as well. I’ve had some neighbor discussions and disputes about trees and needles and limbs and leaves. Boy, it just brings some questions. Very common questions we hear at Ohio Farm Bureau that we’re going to talk about with Leah Curtis. She’s policy counsel with Ohio Farm Bureau for this Legal with Leah. Hello.
Leah Curtis [00:00:31] Hello.
Ty Higgins [00:00:31] So I guess let’s just run down some of the questions that we get almost on a weekly basis about trees and property rights. The first one being, can I trim a tree overhanging the property line?
Leah Curtis [00:00:42] So as a lawyer, I’m going to tell you most these of questions are going to be an “it depends answer,” but yes, generally property owners can clear the airspace over their property with overhanging tree limbs. But you have to remember that your right is also limited by the right of your neighbor. And so you want to make sure you’re not trespassing while you’re doing this trimming. You don’t want to get on their property. You don’t want to put debris on their property, and you don’t want to trim the tree that is on their property. So the other thing to be careful of is making sure you’re not trimming to an extent that you are causing reckless damage to the tree as well. So you can trim it, but you do have to be careful about it.
Ty Higgins [00:01:17] So really it’s just a matter of being neighborly, but maybe bring an expert into the situation if you don’t know a lot about trees. Someone might be able to help you out there at the county level for sure. What can happen if I damage a neighbor’s tree?
Leah Curtis [00:01:28] So what the law says is you are prohibited from recklessly damaging a tree on another’s property without their permission. So this actually is a fourth degree misdemeanor. It can carry a penalty of up to $250 or 30 days in jail. In my time, I have not seen anybody go to jail for tree damage, but not saying it can’t happen. And then in addition to that penalty, the law says that if you violate that law, you can be subject to damages up to three times the worth of the tree. So those damages could be awarded through criminal prosecution and restitution, or someone could sue you in a civil lawsuit to get those damages as well. So kind of either way. So it really is that damage provision that’s the real biggie. Three times the value of a tree can be a lot of money, very quickly.
Ty Higgins [00:02:13] Let’s say a tree is right on that property line. Can I take care of it and get rid of it?
Leah Curtis [00:02:17] So this is where the law is really unclear. Under Ohio law, we’ve generally considered trees to be a part of the property. They’re not personal property, they’re real property. And so landowners are considered to have a right to that tree, even if it’s only halfway on their property. So it’s always the best practice to talk to your neighbor about this. If you want to remove a tree that sits on that property line, you can then also have a discussion about how you’re going to pay for it. If somebody needs to enter the property to safely remove the tree, how you’re going to dispose of the tree and the debris. Discussing all those details ahead of time is going to save you a lot of headaches, save you money, save you frustration and discussion afterwards.
Ty Higgins [00:02:54] My neighbors got a tree. It falls and it damages my property. Who’s liable there?
Leah Curtis [00:02:59] So preface that liability is always determined by a court looking at the individual situation. So we get the question about who’s liable about everything from trees to car accidents, whatever. We can never say who’s for sure going to be liable. But, typically courts have found that landowners are not liable for damage from a falling tree so long as they didn’t have a reason to believe the tree would fall. So if a tree is healthy, looks great, no problems, but it gets struck by lightning or a straight line wind comes in and blows it over. That’s probably not going to be a landowner’s responsibility. If instead that tree very clearly was dead or dying, you knew that it was infested with something that was going to make it fall down, there was a serious risk of it falling and causing damage. Then the landowner might have responsibility for the damage that’s caused.
Ty Higgins [00:03:43] This is literally happening in my neighborhood right now, and the neighborhood Facebook page is going crazy. The utility companies coming in and trimming trees on other people’s property. So can they be stopped?
Leah Curtis [00:03:54] So probably not. Utility companies typically have a right of way that allows them to maintain those trees to protect the utility infrastructure. We have to remember that we love our trees, but our trees can really wreak havoc on that utility infrastructure. And we’re very unhappy when that tree falls on the line and takes out our power. So typically that easement is going to allow them or right away is going to allow them to trim those trees. You should look at the easement on your property. You can do that by looking at your deed, the things that are recorded at the county recorder’s office. That should give you an idea of what the scope or extent of their rights are to trim those trees. This is true, even if utility has never come and trimmed. So we’ve had people call and say, Well, the tree has been there for 20 years. They’ve never trimmed it. Now they’re coming and trimming it and I don’t like it. If they have the easement, they most likely have that right, even if they’ve not exercised it in the past.
See more Q&A about trees and property rights, from Leah Curtis
I'm eternally grateful for the support Ohio Farm Bureau scholarships provided in helping me turn my dreams into reality.Available scholarships
I see the value and need to be engaged in the community I live in, to be a part of the decision-making process and to volunteer with organizations that help make our community better.Leadership development
With not growing up on a farm, I’d say I was a late bloomer to agriculture. I feel so fortunate that I found the agriculture industry. There are so many opportunities for growth.Growing our Generation
Labor has always been an issue, mainly because we are a seasonal operation. So that's a challenge finding somebody who only wants to work three months out of a year, sometimes up to six months.Business Solutions
Farm Bureau involvement has taught me how to grow my professional and leadership experience outside of the workforce and how to do that in a community-centric way.Young Ag Professionals program
If it wasn't for Farm Bureau, I personally, along with many others, would not have had the opportunity to meet with our representatives face to face in Washington.Washington, D.C. Leadership Experience
Ohio Farm Bureau and the Union County Farm Bureau recently filed an amicus brief in a case with potential impacts to farmland preservation programs.Read More
Landowners should have the right to challenge and make sure that a taking is necessary and that it’s limited to what is actually necessary so that the law is upheld.Read More
Ohio Farm Bureau Policy Counsel Leah Curtis discusses the ramifications Prop 12 has on American agriculture and what the next steps for the case will be.Read More
With the announcement of Intel in Licking County, will eminent domain will play a role in finding the land resources for future projects in rural areas?Read More