cornfield sunrise

Ohio Farm Bureau and the Union County Farm Bureau have been involved in a court case, Columbia Gas of Ohio v. Bailey Family/Arno Renner Trust, with potential impacts to farmland preservation programs. A long-awaited decision in that important eminent domain case came out this week: The 3rd District Court of Appeals ruled that Columbia Gas of Ohio did not demonstrate that taking of the property was a necessity, and that further review was warranted of the agricultural easement issue.

“This is a very important outcome for not only the Bailey family and the Arno Renner Trust, but anyone who enters into agricultural easements with the intention for their land to remain in agriculture and not just for their family, but for future generations,” Ohio Farm Bureau shared in a statement. “Our organization got involved to not only highlight the significance of the state’s Farmland Preservation program in this case, but also to emphasize the need for broader eminent domain reform that Ohio Farm Bureau is currently advocating for on behalf of landowners across the state.”

At issue in this case: the land that Columbia Gas of Ohio was seeking has a farmland preservation easement on it that was donated to the state of Ohio.

“The landowner and the state agreed when that gift was made that we’re going to continue to have this land in farmland and in agricultural production,” said Leah Curtis, policy counsel with Ohio Farm Bureau. “We want to make sure that those gifts are respected and that these easements are respected.”

With Farm Bureau, efforts like this always start at the grassroots level and, in this case, Union County Farm Bureau has been involved with this situation from the start, making its concerns with this case known locally.

At the state level, Ohio Farm Bureau was able to work with the landowners and their attorneys by filing an amicus brief that was also joined by the Coalition of Ohio Land Trusts. The brief focused on the ag easement issue, and how a utility line being buried under a property does in fact impact the agricultural use of that property.

Curtis said the point of Ohio Farm Bureau’s amicus brief is to not only support the legal arguments being made, but also to provide some more practical and broader perspective of the impacts that these cases can have on the individual landowner and the larger agricultural community.

“We highlighted that there were lots of agricultural uses that would no longer be available because of the presence of that pipeline,” said Curtis. “For example, things like planting tree crops or building a livestock barn would be wholly prohibited or strictly limited by the presence of that pipeline.”

As for the Bailey family, this decision means spending more time in the field than in the courtroom.

“We’re very thankful the Ohio Farm Bureau and the Union County Farm Bureau had our backs through this entire three-year ordeal,” said Patrick Bailey, a Union County Farm Bureau member. “This fight should never have happened, and we’re disappointed that it came down to such a lengthy legal battle, but we were blessed with so many friends and neighbors showing up to support us, including the Union County SWCD, the Coalition of Ohio Land Trusts and land preservation groups from across the state. Our family hopes we can finally put all of this behind us and get back to focusing on getting this year’s crop in the ground.” 

From here, the case can be appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court, or it will be returned to the trial court for further proceedings in accordance with the Appellate Court’s opinion.

Online extra

Legal with Leah is a podcast featuring Ohio Farm Bureau’s Policy Counsel Leah Curtis discussing topics impacting farmers and landowners. Listen as Curtis breaks down the court ruling.


Ohio Farm Bureau · Legal With Leah – Update On The Columbia Gas V. Bailey Family Arno Renner Trust Case


Labor has always been an issue, mainly because we are a seasonal operation. So that's a challenge finding somebody who only wants to work three months out of a year, sometimes up to six months.
Mandy Way's avatar
Mandy Way

Way Farms

Farm Labor Resources
I appreciate the benefit of having a strong voice in my corner. The extras that are included in membership are wonderful, but I'm a member because of the positive impact to my local and state agricultural communities.
Ernie Welch's avatar
Ernie Welch

Van Wert County Farm Bureau

Strong communities
I see the value and need to be engaged in the community I live in, to be a part of the decision-making process and to volunteer with organizations that help make our community better.
Matt Aultman's avatar
Matt Aultman

Darke County Farm Bureau

Leadership development
Farm Bureau involvement has taught me how to grow my professional and leadership experience outside of the workforce and how to do that in a community-centric way.
Jaclyn De Candio's avatar
Jaclyn De Candio

Clark County Farm Bureau

Young Ag Professionals program
With not growing up on a farm, I’d say I was a late bloomer to agriculture. I feel so fortunate that I found the agriculture industry. There are so many opportunities for growth.
Jenna Gregorich's avatar
Jenna Gregorich

Coshocton County Farm Bureau

Growing our Generation
Knowing that horticulture is under the agriculture umbrella and having Farm Bureau supporting horticulture like it does the rest of ag is very important.
Jared Hughes's avatar
Jared Hughes

Groovy Plants Ranch

Groovy Plants Ranch
If it wasn't for Farm Bureau, I personally, along with many others, would not have had the opportunity to meet with our representatives face to face in Washington.
Austin Heil's avatar
Austin Heil

Hardin County Farm Bureau

Washington, D.C. Leadership Experience
So many of the issues that OFBF and its members are advocating for are important to all Ohioans. I look at OFBF as an agricultural watchdog advocating for farmers and rural communities across Ohio.
Mary Smallsreed's avatar
Mary Smallsreed

Trumbull County Farm Bureau

Suggested Tags: